Compensation for Unlawful Immigration Detention
Being detained by the Home Office is one of the most distressing experiences a person can face. If you were held in immigration detention unlawfully, or for longer than the law allows, you may be entitled to claim compensation (damages) from the Home Office.
At Deluxe Law Chambers, our specialist immigration and civil litigation solicitors help people across the UK hold the Home Office to account for unlawful detention. Whether you were held in an Immigration Removal Centre, a short-term holding facility, a police station or a prison under immigration powers, we can assess your case.
Ask our expert immigration solicitors a question for free. Complete our online enquiry form and one of our solicitors will respond as soon as possible.
Free Initial Assessment of Your Unlawful Detention Claim
If our initial review shows you have an arguable claim for compensation, we will offer you a free initial consultation to assess your eligibility for damages and explain your options clearly, with no obligation.
No Win No Fee Unlawful Immigration Detention Claims
We understand that many people leaving detention face financial hardship. That’s why our compensation solicitors can act on a No Win No Fee basis in claims against the Home Office.
- No upfront legal fees. You pay nothing to start your claim.
- Nothing to pay if your claim is unsuccessful.
- If you win, our success fee is capped at up to 25% of the compensation recovered from the Home Office.
We will explain the full terms of the funding agreement in writing before you commit to anything.
Can I Claim Compensation for Unlawful Immigration Detention?
You may have a claim if, for example:
- You were detained when there was no realistic prospect of removal from the UK;
- Your detention continued for an unreasonable length of time;
- The Home Office failed to act quickly and diligently to arrange your removal;
- You were a vulnerable person (such as a victim of torture or trafficking, or someone with serious mental or physical health conditions) and the Home Office failed to follow its Adults at Risk policy or Rule 35 procedures;
- You were detained for a purpose other than deportation or removal;
- The Home Office failed to follow its own published detention policies;
- You were a British citizen, or had a lawful right to be in the UK, at the time of detention.
Who Has to Prove What? The Burden of Proof
In a claim for unlawful immigration detention (the tort of false imprisonment), the claimant only needs to prove that they were detained. Once detention is established, the burden shifts to the Secretary of State for the Home Department to prove that the detention was lawful throughout.
This is a significant advantage for people bringing a claim, and it is one of the reasons why expert legal representation can make a real difference.
The Legal Principles on Unlawful Immigration Detention: The Hardial Singh Principles
The Home Office’s power to detain is not unlimited. The common law places strict limits on the Secretary of State’s detention powers. These were set out by Woolf J (as he then was) in R v Governor of Durham Prison, ex parte Hardial Singh [1984] 1 WLR 704:
“First of all, it [the 1971 Act] can only authorize detention if the individual is being detained in one case pending the making of a deportation order, in the other, pending his removal. It cannot be used for any other purpose. Secondly, as the power is given in order to enable the machinery of the deportation to be carried out, I regard the power of detention as being impliedly limited to a period which is reasonably necessary for that purpose. What is more, if there is a situation where it is apparent to the Secretary of State that he is not going to be able to operate the machinery provided in the Act for removing persons who are intended to be deported within a reasonable period, it seems to me that it would be wrong for the Secretary of State to seek to exercise its powers of detention.”
The Supreme Court unanimously endorsed the Hardial Singh principles in the landmark case of R (Lumba and Mighty) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2011] UKSC 12. At paragraph 22, the Court approved the summary given by Dyson LJ in R (I) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] EWCA Civ 888 at paragraph 46:
“(i) The SSHD must intend to deport the person and can only use the power to detain for that purpose;
(ii) The deportee may only be detained for the period that is reasonable in all the circumstances;
(iii) If, before the expiry of a reasonable period, it becomes apparent that the SSHD will not be able to effect deportation within that reasonable period, [s]he should not seek to exercise the power of detention;
(iv) The Secretary of State should act with reasonable diligence and expedition to effect removal.”
The Four Hardial Singh Principles in Plain English
In R (Muhammad) v SSHD [2017] EWHC 745 (Admin), Michael Fordham QC (sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge) neatly summarised the four principles as:
- The purpose principle: detention must be for the purpose of deportation or removal only.
- The duration principle: detention must last no longer than is reasonable in all the circumstances.
- The removability principle: if it becomes clear that removal cannot happen within a reasonable period, detention must end.
- The diligence principle: the Home Office must act with reasonable diligence and speed to remove the person.
A breach of any one of these principles may render your detention unlawful.
What Is a “Reasonable Period” of Detention?
There is no fixed time limit. At paragraph 48 of R (I), Dyson LJ explained that the relevant factors include at least:
- The length of the period of detention;
- The nature of the obstacles preventing deportation;
- The diligence, speed and effectiveness of the steps taken by the Home Office to overcome those obstacles;
- The conditions in which the detained person is being kept;
- The effect of detention on the detained person and their family;
- The risk that the person will abscond if released; and
- The danger that the person will commit criminal offences if released.
How Much Compensation Can I Get for Unlawful Immigration Detention?
Every case is different, but the courts have developed clear guidance on how damages for false imprisonment should be assessed. Three general principles apply:
- Damages must reflect the individual case. The assessment should be sensitive to the facts and to the degree of harm suffered by the particular claimant.
- No rigid daily rate. Damages should not be calculated mechanistically by fixing a set figure for each day of detention. The court takes a global approach.
- A tapering approach. Although a longer detention is more serious, the amount attributable to the passage of time is generally tapered, or placed on a reducing scale. This is because:
- damages must remain proportionate to awards in personal injury and other cases; and
- the initial shock of being detained usually attracts a higher rate of compensation than its continuation.
Starting Points for Compensation
In Thompson v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [1998] QB 498, the Court of Appeal gave guidance that in a straightforward case of wrongful arrest and imprisonment, the starting point was around £500 for the first hour of lost liberty, and around £3,000 for 24 hours of wrongful detention.
As Thompson was decided in 1997, these figures must be adjusted for inflation. They must also be increased by the 10% uplift introduced by the Court of Appeal in Simmons v Castle following the Jackson reforms (see below). Adjusted in this way, the starting points were approximately £1,000 for the first hour and £6,000 for 24 hours of wrongful detention in July 2019 values, and they will be higher today.
The 10% Uplift in General Damages
Following the Jackson reforms to litigation funding (which meant success fees could no longer be recovered as costs from the losing party), general damages were increased by 10% for:
- pain, suffering and loss of amenity in personal injury claims;
- nuisance;
- defamation; and
- all other torts which cause suffering, inconvenience or distress to individuals, including false imprisonment.
Factors That Can Increase Your Compensation
Drawing on the leading cases, the following factors are likely to increase the damages awarded for unlawful immigration detention:
- The initial shock of detention;
- Particular vulnerability: for example, victims of torture or trafficking, people with mental health conditions, or children. This affects the basic award even where the threshold for aggravated damages is not met;
- Poor conduct by the Home Office in the initial detention or afterwards;
- The impact on you, such as a deterioration in your mental health, or on others, such as your children;
- Good character and reputational damage;
- High-handed treatment, such as unnecessary use of handcuffs or being denied a phone call;
- Unlawful detention combined with unlawful removal from the UK.
In serious cases, the court may also award aggravated damages and, exceptionally, exemplary damages for oppressive, arbitrary or unconstitutional conduct by state officials.
Factors That Can Reduce Your Compensation
The following factors are likely to reduce the damages awarded:
- Litigation risk when settling. A negotiated settlement without trial will usually be lower than the amount a claimant might obtain if successful in court;
- Unlawful detention following a period of lawful detention. The “initial shock” element is absent, and the longer the lawful period compared with the unlawful period, the greater the likely effect on damages;
- The tapering effect. The highest damages usually relate to the initial shock and the first 24 hours. However, evidence highlighted in the Shaw Report suggests the tapering effect should be limited in immigration cases. Unlike prisoners serving fixed sentences, immigration detainees often suffer increasing harm over time because they do not know when, or if, their detention will end;
- The claimant’s own conduct, where it is responsible for the length or conditions of detention (although conduct such as hunger strikes is treated with care by the courts).
Is There a Time Limit to Claim?
Yes, and the time limits can be short. Different limitation periods may apply depending on whether your claim is brought for false imprisonment, personal injury, or under the Human Rights Act 1998 (where the deadline can be as short as one year). Contact us as soon as possible so we can protect your position.
Why Choose Deluxe Law Chambers?
- Specialist expertise in immigration law and claims against the Home Office;
- No Win No Fee representation available;
- Free initial assessment of your claim;
- Clear, honest advice about your prospects and likely compensation;
- Experience representing vulnerable clients, including survivors of torture and trafficking;
- Nationwide service across England and Wales.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue the Home Office for unlawful detention?
Yes. If you were detained without lawful authority, or for longer than was reasonable, you can bring a claim for damages for false imprisonment against the Secretary of State for the Home Department.
Do I need to still be in the UK to make a claim?
Not necessarily. People who have been removed or deported can sometimes still bring claims for unlawful detention. Contact us to discuss your circumstances.
How long does an unlawful detention claim take?
Many claims settle through negotiation, which can take several months. Claims that go to trial take longer. We will keep you updated at every stage.
Can I claim if I was released on immigration bail?
Yes. Being released does not prevent you from claiming compensation for a past period of unlawful detention.
Speak to Our Unlawful Detention Solicitors Today
If you believe you were unlawfully detained by the Home Office, Deluxe Law Chambers is here to help. Complete our free online enquiry form or call our team today for a confidential, no-obligation assessment of your unlawful immigration detention compensation claim.